The Best Crib Mattresses that your Baby will Love (with Reviews)

– Crib Mattress Reviews –

Welcome to my blog. My Name is Hannah Stevenson and this blog is born out of my passion for baby crib mattresses.

I am the mother of four kids and I care too much for them for a good night’s sleep.

I have researched and tested a lot of baby crib mattresses for my kids and here I will share my reviews and thoughts on it so that you can choose the best crib mattress for your baby.

Here in my blog, I have written honest reviews about many of the best crib mattresses.

I have also mentioned some of the best budget crib mattresses which are meant for short-term purposes. You can consider that if you have a tight budget and is in need of a cheap crib mattress.

comparison of crib mattresses

A crib mattress is actually a mini mattress designed to fit into the baby crib for giving a comfortable sleep to your baby. It gives additional support and a safer surface for your baby to sleep on. Before choosing a crib mattress, you should go through a large number of reviews for getting the best crib mattress for you.

You can find lots of reviews and general information in this blog that’ll lead to a better crib mattress for your baby.

Best Baby Crib Mattresses Comparison Chart

If you’re in a little hurry, then this comparison chart will definitely help you.

Brand/ModelTypePriceEditor's Rating

Naturepedic No Compromise Organic Cotton Ultra 252
Organic$$$$5/5
Safety 1st Transitions Baby and Toddler
Foam$4.8/5

Sealy Soybean Foam Core
Foam$$$4.8/5

Naturepedic No Compromise Organic Cotton Classic 150
Organic$$$$4.9/5
Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White
Foam$4.6/5
Dream On Me Foam Graco Pack and Play
Foam$4.5/5
Naturepedic No Compromise Organic Cotton Classic
Organic$$$$4.8/5

Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer
Foam$$$4.7/5

Sealy Soybean Serenity Organic
Organic$$4.7/5
Colgate Eco Classica I
Foam$$$4.5/5

Sealy Baby Posturepedic
Inner Spring$$4.4/5

My First Mattress Memory Foam

Foam$$4.6/5

Kolcraft Pure Sleep Therapeutic 150
Inner Spring$4.4/5

Sealy Baby Firm Rest
Foam$4.5/5

Top Picks and Reviews

Best Crib Mattress (Overall)

Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Crib Mattress

Sealy Soybean Foam Core Crib Mattress

From my experience of owning and testing several crib mattresses for my kids, I can say that Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Mattress is absolutely the best one among all the different choices available. This is the best hypoallergenic and lightweight crib mattress available in the market and many of my friends are using this.

Moreover, this mattress is reasonably priced and I promise this is really worth the money. The mattress is firm and does not sway at all in the middle portion.

This is a healthy and non-toxic crib mattress that contains no flame-retardant chemicals at all. The mattress cover is waterproof and stain-resistant.

Also Great

Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Crib Mattress

Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Dual Firmness All Foam Crib Mattress

Like the above #1 mattress Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer All Foam Crib Mattress is also a dual firm foam mattress. This is also my favorite foam mattress which I highly recommend. I love this product as it is made of medical-grade foam and is lightweight which aids in those late-night sheet changes.

No harsh chemicals or low-grade materials are used in this product and are made of eco-friendly materials.

This mattress is side stitched and both of its ends are firm. Moreover, Moonlight Slumber is a trustworthy brand that specializes in baby crib mattresses.

If you are concerned about the expense, this is worth every penny you spend and you get a superior quality foam mattress by spending a little more. I highly recommend this product to all my readers. Buy this product and never look back, you will never regret it!!

Best Value Crib Mattress

Colgate Eco Classica III  Crib mattress

Colgate Eco Classica III Dual Firmness Eco-Friendlier Crib Mattress

The Colgate Eco Classica III is a very good option for your baby if you are looking for a high-quality dual firmness organic crib mattress.

This is a little expensive mattress but still, it’s worth the extra money you spend.

Why I love this mattress is that it is very lightweight which makes sheet changes with little effort and it got no smell at all which is really great as my child’s face spends a lot of time cheek-to-cheek with this.

Also, this is a dual-sided mattress with a very firm infant side and a much comfortable and firm toddler side. In addition to all these things, this is a completely organic and eco-friendly mattress and is available at such a great value price.

Best Cheap Crib Mattress

Safety First Heavenly Dreams Crib Mattress

Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib Mattress

The Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams is the best cheap crib mattress I have ever used for my kids.

 If you are planning to use your crib mattress for only a shorter period, then this one is highly recommended as it is available at a very cheap price.

Even if this is cheap, it is a very standard and great crib mattress with a very high density and thermo-bonded at the core.

This is a very lightweight as well as a firmer mattress and easily works as a toddler bed mattress. Moreover, this product is from a highly trustworthy brand Safety 1st.

This is ultimately the best option for you if you have a limited or less budget. 

Best Organic Crib Mattress

Naturepedic Organic Cotton Classic Crib Mattress

Naturepedic No Compromise Organic Cotton Classic

Without any doubt, the Naturepedic No Compromise Organic Cotton Crib Mattress is the best organic crib mattress available in the market.

This is built out of 100% high-quality organic materials increasing the safety of your baby.

These days, most parents prefer organic crib mattresses as they are very much concerned about their baby’s safety. Organic mattresses are the most safest and comfortable when compared with other non-organic mattresses.

Naturepedic organic mattresses are costly but it is absolutely worth the extra money you spend as your child’s comfort and safety are the most important.

Reviews of the 5 Best Crib Mattresses

It was really hard for me to choose the best out of such a large number of great baby crib mattresses. Here goes my list which is prepared based on customer satisfaction as well as my own experience.

Sealy Soybean Foam Core Crib Mattress

1. Sealy Soybean Foam Core Crib Mattress

I have already written above why Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Crib Mattress is the best out of all. This is a quite expensive mattress with great build quality and safety which will compensate for the extra money you spend on it.

2. Simmons Kids Beautyrest 2 n 1 Crib and Toddler Mattress

Simmons Kids Beautyrest Beginnings Sleepy Whispers Ultra Deluxe Crib and Toddler Mattress

This mattress from Simmons is another great choice for your baby crib mattress. This is a GREENGUARD GOLD-certified mattress with a limited lifetime warranty and is one of the best non-organic crib mattresses. It has no smell and is made of superior quality materials. Sure, it comes with an above-average price tag, but it is worth the money you spend.

3. Naturepedic Classic 150 Seamless Dual Firmness Crib Mattress

Naturepedic No Compromise Organic Cotton Classic

The Naturepedic produces the finest organic crib mattress for your baby. I highly recommend organic crib mattresses as they are completely free from chemicals and other toxins. The Naturepedic No Compromise Organic Cotton Class 150 is dual firmness crib mattress that provides 100% good sleep for your baby.

It is one of the best-rated organic crib mattresses available in the market.

Go for the best eco-friendly crib mattress for your baby from Naturepedic.

Once you buy, you will never regret it. It is really worth spending on an organic crib mattress if you want the safest mattress for your baby. It is worth every penny you spend on it.

Highly valued and recommended product.

4. Colgate Classica I Foam Crib Mattress

Colgate Classica I Foam Crib Mattress

The Colgate Classica I is a lightweight and water-resistant crib mattress that assures a comfortable sleep for your baby.

This mattress has the safest corners which add to the safety of the crib mattress. This is the best option if you are looking for the safest memory foam crib mattress for your baby and also you can enjoy the benefits of owning a product from the house of Colgate.

It is known to have high durability and a limited lifetime warranty. This is a bit expensive mattress but overall this is a great choice.

5. Sealy Baby Firm Rest Crib Mattress

Sealy Baby Firm Rest Crib Mattress

The Sealy Baby Firm Crib Mattress is yet another choice for your new born baby.

This is a well-built mattress with heat-tempered coils which provide a firm support to your baby. It is provided with two thick hypoallergenic layers which offer better comfort and support.

This is a GREENGUARD Gold Certified baby crib mattress.

Moreover, this product comes with a 20-year limited warranty which makes me highly recommend this crib mattress for your baby. You don’t need to worry about anything.

What are the Different Types of Crib Mattresses ?

During the first year, the baby snoozes upwards for about 16 hours a day and a crib mattress is essential for the baby’s comfort. There are different types of crib mattresses available in the market. Crib mattresses are classified on the basis of their core content. The material that forms the core decides the level of comfort and firmness of the crib mattress.

The most commonly used types are

1. Foam Crib Mattress

foam crib mattress

As the name suggests, this type of baby crib mattress is made using one or more blocks of foam. The core contains foam as the only material. A foam mattress can be made using different varieties of materials such as Polyurethane, Bamboo Fibre, Latex etc.

The foam crib mattress is the cheapest option when compared with other types.

When you choose, make sure you know the type of foam inside the mattress, latex foam is more long-lasting, comfortable, and expensive when compared with polyurethane and bamboo fiber-made foams. Generally, the foam mattress is preferred because of its lightweight and portability.

You can easily carry this mini-mattress without any hassle.

It is always recommended to select a denser and firmer foam mattress as it provides more comfort and safety for your baby.

The Good

  • Very cheap price
  • Portable and light weight
  • Different varieties of foam material available
  • Widely used
  • Available in different size and thickness

The Bad

  • Not durable when compared with others
  • This is not an option if you are looking for a long term solution
foam crib mattress
best foam crib mattress

Reviews of the Best Rated Foam Crib Mattresses

2. Coil or Inner Spring Crib Mattress

inner spring crib mattress

In this type of mattress, the core is made up of coiled steel springs and is much heavier than a foam mattress. Coil count and thickness of the steel used are the major things you have to consider when you go for a spring crib mattress. Actually, the thickness of steel matters more than the coil count as more number of coils doesn’t mean a firmer mattress.

The thickness of the steel used is a major factor that decides the comfort and safety of the mattress. So before you buy an innerspring crib mattress take this factor into consideration. This mattress provides a good level of comfort as it got a steel frame to which each spring coil is joined.

When a weight is placed on the mattress, the spring will get compressed to a particular degree.

It is always recommended that you avoid cheap quality spring mattresses as they will get squeaked easily on baby’s movement.

The Good

  • Long lasting ,safer and comfortable
  • Good support and high durability
  • Available at reasonable prices

The Bad

  • It is heavier.
  • Expensive when compared with foam mattresses
  • Low quality spring coils will get squeaked easily

Reviews of the Best Rated Coil Spring Crib Mattresses

3. Pocket Spring Crib Mattress

pocket spring

This is very similar to the above-discussed coil spring mattress. The main difference between them is that the coils of steel are not connected to one another instead they are fixed into their own material pocket.

This ensures independent movement of each spring and it gets compressed depending on the amount of weight placed on it.

The main advantage of using a pocket spring crib mattress is that the spring supporting the baby’s back portion will get compressed more than the spring supporting the baby’s legs.

This ensures better overall comfort for your baby.

The Good

  • Better overall comfort as springs will get compressed individually in its own pockets
  • High durability
  • Very good support

The Bad

  • Little expensive when compared with other crib mattresses

Reviews of the Best Rated Pocket Spring Crib Mattresses

4. Memory Foam Type Crib Mattress

memory foam crib mattress

This type of crib mattress possesses the unique feature of having a temperature-sensitive foam that adjusts to the baby’s body shape.

The spring-back action of this type of foam is slow and thus gives more safety and comfort to your baby.

The foam mattress is initially hard during cold but as the baby lays down on the mattress, the foam slowly adjusts to the shape of the baby.

This mattress is commonly used during cold times as it provides more warmness to the baby’s body due to its specific design that reduces air circulation.

The memory foam mattress cannot be flipped as it constitutes a coiled spring core and a layer of memory foam on top of it.

Both memory foam and foam crib mattresses are almost the same and they have very little difference.

The Good

  • Better warmth due to reduced air circulation
  • Adjusts to the baby’ body shape for better comfort
  • Spring backs slowly to its original shape providing better safety

The Bad

  • Not suitable for summer season as it may be too hot
  • No flipping of mattress

5. Organic and Natural Crib Mattress

Naturepedic No Compromise Organic Cotton Classic Crib Mattress

The conventional crib mattress is made of chemically obtained materials such as petroleum by-products and treated with chemicals like boric acid etc.

If you are a parent like me who feels that your baby should not be introduced to such types of chemically made crib mattresses, then go for the organic and naturally made crib mattresses.

These Organic mattresses are completely made from natural materials which are 100% chemical-free.

The organic materials used for making crib mattresses are ;

  • Non-Treated Wool : Natural flame retardant and Dust Resistant
  • Organic Cotton : Completely chemical free cotton which is breathable
  • Natural Latex : Used as an alternative to foams made with petroleum by products
  • Coconut Fiber : 100% Breathable
organic mattress

Despite being advertised as 100% natural, some mattresses may contain chemically made materials to a small extent. Therefore, be sure to read plenty of customer reviews and check the product descriptions before you make a purchase.

Naturepedic is one of the best makers of organic crib mattresses.

The Good

  • Better lasting and comfort
  • No harmful chemicals
  • Made from natural and organic materials
  • Highly breathable

The Bad

  • Expensive
  • Firmness and comfort depends on the materials used
  • Good research is required before making a purchase

Reviews of the Best Rated Organic Crib Mattresses

How to Pick the Best Crib Mattress that Suits You

Getting the best crib mattress for your baby is a real challenge as you need to consider a lot of things before buying. There are a large number of crib mattresses available in the market and I am here to help you choose the best.

Consider the following things

1. Crib Mattress Cover Material

Know your mattress cover material as the cover has got two important functions;

  • Provides protection to the mattress core
  • Prevents inside mattresses from falling out

Different mattress covers are available. Some are waterproof which helps in preventing urine and other liquids to soak into the mattress core.

Some are made of very thin material and some are made strong with nylon to prevent the chances of holes and tears on the mattress.

2. Crib Mattress Firmness

It is advisable to buy a firm mattress as this is the safest one for your baby. There is a suffocation risk with soft mattresses. To know whether the mattress is firm or soft, just press the center and edge of the mattress with your hand.

3. Check whether the Mattress is Hypoallergenic or not

It is better to buy a hypoallergenic crib mattress for your baby as it will not irritate or cause any kind of allergies for your baby. This is the best for those babies who have asthma or allergies.

4. Check the Mattress Ventilation

Some mattresses have vents in the sides for better air circulation through the mattress.

Good air circulation through the baby’s mattress is necessary for the baby’s health.

So go for the ones with better air ventilation.

5. Consider the Weight of the Mattress

It is recommended to get a lighter mattress as it will help in lifting it more easily.

The crib sheets need to be changed every week and you need to lift the mattress each time you change the sheet.

So a bulkier mattress will make your work more difficult. Therefore go for a lighter crib mattress.

6. Check whether the Mattress is Flame Retardant or Not

All mattresses sold in the US should meet various flammability standards. Check for those standards.

How to Choose the Best Crib Mattress for your Baby ?

Here is a video guide below that tells how to select the best baby crib mattress. Do check it out.

For more tips, you can read our detailed guide onHow to Buy the Best Crib Mattress ‘.

A Few Final Words

All the above-listed baby crib mattresses are highly recommended and I have personally tested and used most of them.

Every kind of mattress has its own specialties and comfort level. So feel free to choose any of the above-listed mattresses and make sure your baby gets the most comfortable sleep.

I have done my best (with a help of a technical friend) to bring out 100% genuine crib mattress reviews for you.

In addition to the honest reviews, I have also managed to provide some great information that will help your crib mattress last for many years.